Actor Headshot Myths Debunked: What Really Matters for Casting
Actor Headshot Advice by Marc Cartwright
In the acting world, outdated advice spreads quickly; especially when it comes to headshots. Many photographers and industry professionals still hear the same myths repeated year after year. These misconceptions often lead actors to make choices that feel safe or traditional but don’t actually help them stand out in today’s casting environment.
Your headshot is not just a picture—it’s a storytelling tool. Understanding what matters (and what doesn’t) helps you walk into your session with clarity and confidence.
Here are some of the most common headshot myths actors should stop believing.
Myth 1: “I Need a Headshot With a Big Smile So I Look Friendly.”
A smile can be great—if it’s connected and authentic.
But just showing teeth is not a universal requirement for a good headshot.
Casting wants:
Story
Presence
Emotion
A clear sense of who you are
A forced or generic smile is often less effective than a grounded, natural expression that reveals something truthful.
Myth 2: “I Shouldn’t Wear Certain Colors.”
Actors often think they need to avoid:
White
Black
Bold colors
Neutrals
But the truth is: almost any color works if it supports your energy and doesn’t distract from your face.
Rather than limiting yourself, focus on:
Colors that complement your skin tone
Shades that support your casting
Tones that enhance your emotional vibe
Context matters more than strict rules.
Myth 3: “I Need to Look Perfect.”
Perfection doesn’t book jobs; connection does.
Trying to look flawless often results in:
Stiff posture
Forced expressions
Overly retouched images
A version of yourself that doesn’t match your casting
Headshots are most powerful when they’re honest and grounded, not airbrushed into idealized versions of you.
Myth 4: “Headshots Should Look Like Glamour Photos.”
Glamour and headshots are not the same thing.
Headshots prioritize:
Authentic emotion
Natural expression
Real-world casting
Subtlety over polish
High-fashion lighting, dramatic styling, and heavy makeup often pull focus away from the story you’re telling as an actor.
Myth 5: “I Just Need One Image to Do Everything.”
Most actors benefit from having multiple intentional looks, such as:
A warm, commercial-friendly look
A grounded, dramatic look
A more intense or emotionally complex look
A professional/corporate look (if needed)
You don’t need to get overly specific or costumey with your photos, but you should have an assortment that reflects the character essences you can genuinely play.
Using only one photo rarely gives casting a strong sense of direction, so it often lands flat. When someone says they want one shot that “does everything,” I ask: How would that even work? For instance: You can’t look trustworthy and untrustworthy at the same time. If casting is looking for someone trustworthy and your photo is neutral, the actor whose image leans clearly into that more trusting quality is far more likely to get the call.
Casting directors are creative, but they’re also busy and can be overwhelmed with submissions. When they’re searching for a specific type, the actor whose photo leans clearly into that type is more likely to get the audition.
Multiple intentional looks aren’t about pigeonholing yourself. They help casting quickly understand what you bring to the table and call you in for the roles that fit.
Myth 6: “Wardrobe Doesn’t Matter.”
Wardrobe shapes perception instantly.
The right clothing supports your character lane, tone, and emotional energy.
Good wardrobe helps casting see:
Your professionalism
Your sense of style
Your natural presence
Your alignment with specific genres
Wardrobe is part of the storytelling—not an afterthought.
Why Understanding These Myths Matters
When actors hold onto outdated ideas about headshots, they often end up with images that feel generic or mismatched to their goals. Breaking free of these myths allows you to approach your session with honesty, precision, and a clearer understanding of your type.
Today’s casting environment values authenticity.
The more your headshots reflect who you truly are, the more likely they are to connect.
Read the Full Article on Backstage
You can read the complete version of my original article here:
“Headshot Photography Myths—Busted!”
(Opens in a new tab.)Need Guidance Choosing Looks, Wardrobe, or Expression?
I help actors create intentional headshots that reflect their casting, personality, and emotional range.
Explore my portfolio or book a session in Los Angeles:
